Brooklyn Pizza in Birmingham

Ahhhhh real pizza, true N.Y. style which is the best in the us.

I waited for ever even though I was the only customer at the counter. The pizza was slappy. I am not buying anymore

Have such great pizza and is always ready to give you ice cream after

So good! Real New York feel. Best Pizza, Family loved it!

This is our favorite pizza joint!

I know pizza, specifically New York style pizza. Due to traffic it took me 20 minutes to get there and 25 back to home. My pizza was hot when I got it, but the box was cold by the time I reached home. Popped the slices into the microwave. Amazing!

This pizza has NEVER disappointed, not once! So tasty 🤗

Cheese pizza was really good

Always on point

The pizza was okay, but the price was ridiculous. Cost $15 for a small pizza with 2 toppings that wasn’t even enough to fill up one person. Would eat again, but not for that price.

a large pizza for $20? you'd think it was a practical joke, but it's not. it's not even good pizza, at that. save your cash and just get a little caesar's.

Still the BEST after all these years

Best NY style pizza in the area.

Wow. Great pizza! Pepperoni, well done- 6 slices later doesn’t get much better.

Veg friendly pizza! the Brussels pizza is dope. I’m so glad there is an affordable place with delicious and quick food left in Birmingham. Support this great business!

Good pizza. New York style. Lots of choices. A but noisy, but okay.

For being American it is good! (I am Italian)

Pizza was really good. Service was quick and convinent. Prices are also very reasonable.

Not as good as it used to be. Not sure why but it's become too Midwestern. If that makes any sense. Not the edgy Brooklyn style like in the beginning. Maybe people just didn't get it and they had to change a bit to make everyone happy. Not sure. Still good, just not Brooklyn good.

This pizza was amazing

Excellent wood fired pizzas! Very tasty slices ready to go and nice variety to choose from. They also offer gelato to finish it all off with!

I always come by getting some food in this place. I liked the prompt customer service and well cooked food. Kudos.

Yummy pizza! The bathrooms could use some attention. Pretty cool that you can get a slice

It's a decent place good pizzas but totally lacks the vibe. The menus and menu boards are not updated. The people behind the counter are not very ethusiastic. Unfortunate, cause it's located in such a great neighborhood filled with some of the best places to eat.

Good varieties of pizzas slices to choose from. You can also order your own whole pizza. They have a little ice cream shop inside as well. Brooklyn Pizza has been around forever, for good reason. Its excellent pizza. Large, thin crust slices.

Has the best beef pepperoni pizza in the area. Freshness of ingredients and flavor profiles are always consisted.

REAL New York pizza!

I used to go here after working downtown Birmingham and occasionally would get a slice or whole pizza for free. Haven’t stepped inside in about 18 years, I’m long overdue, my family and I will venture there soon as we’ll be visiting from Oregon....

Tastiest thin crust pizza and yummiest ice cream and very friendly staff

This review is for the food only. The service was perfect. The food on the other hand, was sub-par especially for the price. Barely warm, little to no sauce, flavorless chicken, definitely not worth $30. I will never go back.

A local staple. Good pizza and the only place to grab ice cream in Birmingham for the time being.

Best NY-style pizza in the Metro area! Great pizza, perfect crust, good sauce, great cheese. My wife and I were born and raised on Long Island, and this pizza is every bit as good as what you'll find in NYC. Owner is from Flatbush. Highly recommend!

If you want thin crust pizza and you are not in Detroit, this is the place to be. You will not be disappointed, though to be fair, it is better to eat in rather than take out. The pizza slices are generous sizes and there is a great ratio of cheese, sauce, and topping on top of the crust that is not too thin nor too thick. Being from NY I have to be a bit tougher on this place and I give it higher marks for its creativity. In fact it's usually those pizzas I would order over the classical/traditional ones. Definitely a fun place to bring friends/family for a quick lunch/snack.

Mushroom cheese Pizza is amazing!

Good pizza, but nasty attitude. They pick their toppings for you? Asked for extra sauce and they put tomatoes on top saying it’s the same thing!!!!!!!

The best pizza in town

Like it, becoming a regular.

A great spot to grab a quick lunch. Thin crust pizza's with several topping varieties. My favorite is the 'Four Cheese' & 'Buffalo Chicken.'

Fast service,pretty good

My favorite pizza place. Fresh thin slice pizza just like NYC. Love it.

Great pizza, relatively cheap, and one of the few casual lunch spots in downtown Birmingham.

The best slice of Pizza in Oakland county. The name says it all. Brooklyn style Pizza with all the ambiance to go with it.

Their brick oven thin crust pizza is delicious! The ingredients are fresh. I used to come here years ago when they had a lunch special with pizza, drink and ice cream for a fixed price. They got me hooked. Pricier then your regular pizza place, but well worth it.

Great place to grab a pie. Either by the slice or whole pizza.

Fantastic pizza. My favorite lunch spot in Birmingham. The buffalo chicken pizza is phenomenal.

Terrible management there, everyone is clueless. I placed order online to find out it didn't get delivered after 1 hour, then I called them and they said it's being made and on way soon. Nothing happened so I then drove to the place and find them confused and didn't realize I placed the order online an hour before and then rushed to make my order in 5 minutes. Total waste of time, change the management and fire the current staff. Not worth the time. I don't care of it's good. Go to Primos pizza instead it's way better.

hard to not get, almost every Friday, alright I calmed down, but legit the pizza is really really really good.

Good pizza, could use little better sauce and put it all way to the edges

Got a large mushroom pizza delivered! Hit the spot, thin crust and awesome. Have also gotten their BBQ chicken in store before, also really good!

Been going here for years, there’s no other pizza like it around